Algorithms decide in seconds which properties are surfaced to potential guests and which are quietly buried beneath the competition. Review scores, amenity filters, search relevance and content quality all influence these decisions—and for operators who rely heavily on OTAs, the stakes couldn’t be higher.
PriceLabs’ recent Global Host Report, which surveyed more than 1,400 hosts worldwide, found that 63% worry about their property’s ranking on OTAs, particularly as these platforms continue to drive the majority of bookings.
At the same time, the rules of travel discovery are beginning to shift beyond traditional OTA search. Phocuswright research found that travel search via generative artificial intelligence (AI) platforms more than doubled between the first and second half of 2025. Yet, most of the listings today aren’t structured or optimized to be found and recommended by large language models.
This gap is already visible in performance data. In the Listing Optimization Report from PriceLabs, only 12% of listings received a “good” quality score based on modern platform standards—yet those listings were 35% more likely to outperform their market.
The question becomes: In an environment shaped by algorithmic rankings and emerging AI-driven discovery, what can hosts and property managers do to stay visible and thrive using the tools now at their disposal?
What makes a bad listing?
To understand what separates strong listings from weak ones, the PriceLabs data science team analyzed nearly 10,000 listings across nine global markets, including Barcelona, Chicago, Dubai and Melbourne. Using scoring models trained on millions of listings worldwide, the study evaluated titles, descriptions, images and image order, consistency between photos and amenities and guest review sentiment.
The results were remarkably consistent across markets. Nearly 70% of listings had weak images, often poorly lit, blurry, in a confusing order or failing to highlight the features guests care about most. More than half had unclear or incomplete descriptions, while 54% showed inconsistencies between their descriptions and photos.
This is an industry built on trust. Without a reliable star system and with very few large brands offering consistency across multiple locations, short-term rental (STR) guests rely heavily on listings and reviews. When photos promise one experience and reviews describe another, expectations break down before the guest has even booked.
Misalignment between content and the guest experience sends negative signals to platforms, affecting ranking and visibility. Conversion suffers long before pricing ever enters the equation.
Expectation-setting matters more than ever
Guest reviews offered further insight into how listing quality influences performance. Many recurring complaints identified in the analysis pointed to mismatched expectations rather than operational failures. Parking issues, street noise, unclear instructions or missing amenities frequently appeared in reviews, even when guests were otherwise happy.
These issues stem from hosts not setting realistic expectations before check-in. Without proper information, guests arrive with assumptions that the property cannot meet. This doesn’t have to mean huge guidebooks or strongly worded house rules that put a bad taste in guests’ mouths. Careful word and photo choices can help set expectations.
For example, describing a “cozy apartment in a buzzing central location” helps guests understand in advance that the property might be small and that the streets could be noisy—without focusing on the negatives. Met expectations lead to positive reviews, and the upward cycle continues.
When bookings slow down, operators tweak pricing, yet performance remains flat because the root cause often sits earlier in the guest journey. Setting and meeting—or exceeding—realistic expectations builds trust and makes everything else along the guest journey easier.
Why listing quality breaks down at scale
These challenges are not limited to individual hosts. Professional property managers overseeing large portfolios face additional structural obstacles.
Small inconsistencies replicated across hundreds of listings quickly turn into widespread performance issues and significant missed revenue opportunities. Content workflows are often fragmented, with marketing teams updating descriptions, operations teams managing amenities and owners contributing photos independently.
Manual audits struggle to keep pace under these conditions. Reviewing a handful of listings is manageable, but maintaining consistency across hundreds on an ongoing basis is not. As a result, quality issues persist unnoticed, gradually impacting visibility and revenue across entire portfolios.
AI helps to solve this: It can read hundreds of data points at once, spot inconsistencies with the neutral eye of an algorithm and offer solutions.
Applying revenue thinking to the full guest journey
Revenue management has become widespread in STRs, particularly in the use of dynamic pricing. However, few property managers and even fewer hosts consider revenue management in the broader context. Setting the right price is important, sure, but it isn’t a silver bullet.
Visibility, operations and guest communication require the same discipline operators apply to pricing strategy. Listing quality is a quick win and one area that’s ripe for improvement with the tools available today.
As competition grows and guest expectations continue to rise, listing quality is becoming a defining factor in performance. Operators who recognize this shift have an opportunity to improve visibility and revenue by strengthening one of the most influential parts of the booking journey.
About the author...
Richie Khandelwal is the co-founder of PriceLabs
Tags: Richie Khandelwal PriceLabs short-term rental (STR) Online travel agencies artificial intelligence (AI) Phocuswright research
